All spreadsheet tools

Lease vs Buy Equipment: Compare After Tax, Not by Monthly Payment

Why the monthly payment is not the comparison, and what to compute instead.

Disclosure: Galaxy Forge sells a $39 spreadsheet that implements this method (see the end of the page). This article is complete on its own, and free alternatives exist.

The monthly payment is the wrong comparison. What matters is what each choice costs after tax over the same period, in today's money. This is a calculation method, not tax advice; depreciation rules, Section 179 and bonus limits and lease classification change and depend on your situation, so confirm the treatment with your accountant.

What to put on the buying side

What to put on the leasing side

Any amount due at signing and the lease payments, which are generally deductible, so each payment costs (1 - tax rate) of its face value. Confirm that your lease is a true operating lease.

Worked example

A $85,000 machine bought with 20% down on an 8% five-year loan has a payment of $1,378.79 a month. Leasing it costs $1,650 a month plus $3,300 at signing. At a 26% tax rate, 5-year MACRS, a $30,000 resale value and a 7% discount rate, buying costs $47,280 after tax and leasing costs $63,376: buying is cheaper by $16,097, 18.9% of the price.

On these assumptions the gap is large enough to matter, but it depends on them: test a lower resale value and a different tax rate before relying on it. The resale value is usually the largest uncertainty: change it and watch the answer move.

Mistakes to avoid

If you would rather not build it yourself

The workbook for this method has the formulas already built and checked, with an example filled in and a PDF guide. It costs $39, one time. View it on Gumroad.

New product, listed 2026-11-05: no sales or reviews yet. Example figures are illustrative. This page is general information, not legal, tax, financial or professional advice.